Factors to consider when evaluating Carlson Survey vs Civil 3D

🧰 Functionality & Workflow

• Carlson Survey: Tailored for land surveyors, Carlson Survey offers robust tools for field-to-finish workflows, 3D surface modeling, coordinate geometry (COGO), and point group management. Users appreciate its intuitive interface and the ability to perform tasks without relying heavily on custom objects, which can simplify data sharing and reduce compatibility issues.
• Civil 3D: As part of the Autodesk suite, Civil 3D provides comprehensive features for civil engineering design, including dynamic modeling of surfaces, alignments, and corridors. However, some users find that its reliance on styles and custom objects can complicate workflows, especially for those transitioning from traditional CAD environments.

💵 Cost & Licensing

• Carlson Survey: Available as a perpetual license with optional annual maintenance plan, which includes access to new product enhancements, CAD engine updates, bug fixes, etc. Carlson Survey can be a cost-effective solution for firms seeking long-term value without expensive recurring annual subscription fees. The CAD license can be installed on 2 computers - simultaneous use not permitted. Network licenses are available as well.
• Civil 3D: Offered through a subscription model, Civil 3D requires ongoing monthly or annual payments, which can be a consideration for budget-conscious organizations.

🔄 Compatibility & Integration

• Carlson Survey: Operates as a standalone application using IntelliCAD, embedded AutoCAD engine (Survey OEM), or installed as an add-on to existing AutoCAD or Civil 3D license. This flexibility allows users to choose a platform that best suits their existing workflows and budget. Carlson Survey is compatible with Civil 3D, AutoCAD, and LDD native file formats. A CAD user can import/export dwg/dgn/dxf/landxml retroactive to ACAD 2000. Carlson offers module add-ons for specific project applications including; Construction, Civil, GIS, CADnet, and Point Cloud.
• Civil 3D: Features integration and compatibility with the Autodesk ecosystem only. Limited scope for integrations outside of the Autodesk ecosystem.

🧑💻 User Experience & Learning Curve

• Carlson Survey: Known for its user-friendly interface, Carlson Survey is often praised for its ease of use, especially by professionals familiar with traditional CAD systems. The software's straightforward approach can lead to quicker onboarding and productivity.
• Civil 3D: While powerful, Civil 3D has a steeper learning curve due to its complex style-based system and dynamic modeling capabilities. Users transitioning from other platforms may require additional training to become proficient.

🛠️ Stability & Support

• Carlson Survey: Users find the software reliable and appreciate the responsive customer support. Free phone and email tech support, monthly CAD updates, online knowledge base, webinars, Youtube Channel, custom training solutions, and module based tutorials are available.
• Civil 3D: Generally considered stable, Civil 3D benefits from Autodesk's online user community and cloud updates. Phone support is non-existent and online support is the primary support avenue

📊 Summary Comparison

Check out more info on Carlson Survey or schedule a demo today